Friends,
Please join me in congratulating Immigration Clinic student-attorney Dana Florkowski and her client, S-M, from El Salvador. This morning, after a three-hour hearing, immigration judge (IJ) Quynh Vu Bain granted the asylum application of S-M and her eighteen year-young daughter. The ICE trial attorney waived appeal so the grant is final. This was the fourth asylum grant won by the student-attorneys this semester. Fifteen lives have been saved.
S-M and her abuser met and lived together in the USA. After repeated beatings, rapes, and verbal abuse, S-M called the police, which lead to the abuser’s removal to El Salvador. After his return to El Salvador, the abuser and his brother, who have connections with the Mara 18 gang, threatened to kill S-M’s mother and daughter, who remained there, unless S-M rejoined him. Despite her concerns, S-M decided to return to El Salvador because, as she testified, “I would rather put my life at risk than my daughter’s.” S-M’s US citizen son, the son of her abuser, accompanied her to El Salvador. After her return, the beatings, rapes, and verbal abuse continued. S-M decided to flee El Salvador after the abuser threatened to kill her and turn her daughter over to the Mara 18 gang to be raped. Sadly, S-M and her daughter fled so quickly she had to leave behind her son. During this morning’s hearing, the IJ said she was troubled by S-M’s voluntary return to El Salvador. Dana explained that the return was not voluntary, and she cited the psychological evidence of the abuser’s control over S-M. The IJ concluded that S-M’s return to El Salvador was under duress. Now that S-M and her daughter are safe, the student-attorneys will work to reunite her son, now nine, with her.
Congratulations also to Alyssa Currier, Karoline Núñez, and Jonathan Bialosky, who previously worked on this case.
**************************************************
Alberto Manuel Benitez
Professor of Clinical Law
Director, Immigration Clinic
The George Washington University Law School
650 20th Street, NW
Washington, DC 20052
(202) 994-7463
(202) 994-4946 fax
abenitez@law.gwu.edu
THE WORLD IS YOURS…
*************************************
Lots of good things at work here!
Great representation. Scholarly judging from Judge Bain (certainly how I remember her from Arlington). And, kudos to the DHS Assistant Chief Counsel in Arlington for waiving appeal when justice has been done. This is the way I remember the ICE OCC in Arlington — skilled litigators who properly required critical examination of all claims but also had an overall commitment to fairness, justice, and making the system work!
This is actually a “casebook study” of how the asylum system in Immigration Court is supposed to work. It still could work this way in many, perhaps eventually most, cases if Sessions and the politicos at DOJ would just get out of the way and let the Immigration Judges, respondents’ Counsel, and the DHS Assistant Chief Counsel do their jobs!
Thanks again to Professor Benitez and his team at GW and to all the other clinical, pro bono, “low bono,” and other counsel out there striving every day to see that our justice system actually delivers justice.
PWS
03-08-18