Susan McWilliams writes in The Nation:
While many commentators say Trump will have to bring back jobs or vibrancy to places like the Rust Belt if he wants to continue to have the support of people who voted for him, Thompson’s account suggests otherwise. Many if not most Trump supporters long ago gave up on the idea that any politician, even someone like Trump, can change the direction the wind is blowing. Even if he fails to bring back the jobs, Trump can maintain loyalty in another way: As long as he continues to offend and irritate elites, and as long as he refuses to play by certain rules of decorum—heaven forfend, the president-elect says ill-conceived things on Twitter!—Trump will still command loyalty. It’s the ethic, not the policy, that matters most.
Even the racism that was on full display in Trump’s campaign should be understood at least in part in retaliatory terms, as directed at the political elite rather than at struggling minority groups. The Hells Angels, Thompson wrote, did things like get tattoos of swastikas mostly because it visibly scared the members of polite society. The Angels were perfectly happy to hang out at bars with men of different races, especially if those men drove motorcycles, and several insisted to Thompson that the racism was only for show. While I have no doubt (and no one should have any doubt) that there are genuine racists in Trump’s constituency—and the gleeful performance of racism is nothing to shrug off—Thompson suggests we should consider the ways in which racism might not be the core disease of Trumpism but a symptom of a deeper illness.
* * *
Thompson would also direct our attention in the early days of the Trump administration to the armed forces and the policies that will mandate what they do. For one great exception to the Angels’ ethos of total retaliation against authority was the military, just as one great exception to the Trump voters’ ethos of total irreverence is the police. Thompson explains that such institutions, which are premised on brute force rather than the more refined rules of intellectual engagement, maintain both a practical and a cultural connection to people like the Angels. The military and the police draw mostly from poor and working-class communities to fill their ranks, and their use of violence is something the motorcycle guys understand. It is one aspect of American life they can easily imagine themselves being a part of.
For his part, Thompson thought that what might prove most dangerous about the ethic of total retaliation was the way it encouraged the distrust of all authority—except for the authority of brute force. The president-elect’s enthusiasm for waterboarding and other forms of torture, his hawkish cabinet choices, and his overtures to strongmen like Vladimir Putin are grave omens. We could end up back where Thompson left off at the end of his book: the Angels, marching with the John Birch Society, on behalf of the Vietnam War.
At the end of Hell’s Angels, having spent months with the motorcycle guys, Thompson finally gets stomped by them. For some offense he doesn’t understand (and which he probably didn’t commit), Thompson gets punched, bloodied, kicked in the face and in the ribs, spat at and pissed on. He limps off to a hospital in the dead of night, alone and afraid. Only in that moment does Thompson realize that as a journalist (and therefore a member of the elite), he could not possibly be a true friend of the Angels. Wear leather and ride a motorcycle though he might, Thompson stood on the side of intellectual and cultural authority. And that finally made him, despite his months of good-timing with the Angels, subject to their retaliatory impulses. The ethic of retaliation is total, Thompson comes to realize. There is nothing partial about it. It ends with violence.
There’s no doubt about it: trouble lies ahead. That Hell’s Angels foresaw all this 50 years ago underscores the depth and seriousness of Thompson as a political thinker and of ours as a singularly dangerous time. Trumpism is about something far more serious than Trump, something that has been brewing and building for generations. Let us take Thompson’s cautions seriously, then, so that this time we Berkeley types are not naive about what we face. Otherwise, we’re all liable to get stomped.”
*******************************************
Read the complete, much longer, article at the link.
McWilliams’s article should be a “must read” for every American who can read.
PWS
07-02-17
Trump Time. Or how a tenacious minority controls the government against majorities more used to consensus. Trump tries to be the Don Rickles of politician, gaining political support insulting a small slice of the audience.
Except that Rickles had a sense of humor. Trump is all the meanness of a Rickles barb for no apparent national purpose, from a think skinned undisciplined septuagenarian con man chosen by Russia’s Putin for our leader.. Good grief!
We have had brief experiences with political power safely ensconced through gerrymandering. Like until 2022, when Reapportionment per the 2020 Census will presumably correct most of the rural overrepresentation, now 7+% and growing 1.5% after the 2010 Midterms landslide elected Boehner’s/Ryan’s GOP. And Trump a solid electoral college vote win despite losing the popular vote by 3 million.
The trend accelerates from just minorities having more babies, to more Baby Boomers, the last overwhelmingly “White” (85%) generation passing away.
By 2044, minorities will be a plurality, Whites still a plurality. But few will care then because we are also mixing ethnically even faster. For instance, my grandaughter’s family name is Gilchrist. Nolan’s grandchild’s family name will be Rios. We’re all Mutts, Obama told us. See data at https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2015/demo/p25-1143.pdf , and http://www.pewhispanic.org/2016/09/08/latino-population-growth-and-dispersion-has-slowed-since-the-onset-of-the-great-recession/
Except for the Civil War, which ripped the USA simultaneously by both Slavery in the South and mass Catholic immigration in the North, we traditionally manage demographic transitions peacefully. And fortunately older people don’t do a lot of “stomping”. It will be more like at the Iowa City assisted living facility where my parents listened to the other residents complain all the time about the “difficult to understand” staff. working for minimum wage serving their meals.
And, according to the latest Pew Survey, 7% of Americans who listed themselves as Hispanics list themselves as something else in the next Census. Usually “White”. Like Italian and Jewish Americans did 100 years ago. History doesn’t repeat itself, but it rhymes.